The .17 Aguila/PMC
A Small Game Option for the .17 Mach II ?
By: Eric A. Mayer
While reading the various rimfire shooting forums around the internet, I have come to see a new “want” from owners of .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) rifles. They want to see the Mach II loaded with a game friendly bullet, such as the 20 grain game point that is currently loaded in the .17 HMR. After shooting hundreds of ground squirrels with my Mach II, I can understand the need for a bullet that does not effectively destroy half the edible meat on a small game animal. I know what you’re thinking, the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) is very accurate in the right rifle, so why don’t these hunters just make head-shots on their game? Well, shooting at paper and shooting at an animal that is hiding, moving and simply trying to stay off the BBQ, are two different things. The fact is, a game point in the .17HM2 (.17Mach II) is not an unsubstantiated request. The need is out there, but is likely to go unfilled. There are rumors that Fiocchi Ammunition is coming out with a 20 grain game point offering this fall, but so far my telephone calls to Carlo (Fiocchi America’s Media contact) have gone unanswered, so details are sketchy. Also, word has it that Hornady may offer a full metal jacket version of their .17HM2 (.17 Mach II), however that too is not available yet and we have no target date for release. Other than those options, the likelihood of a 20 grain game point in the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) seems to be a far-off prospect.
So, what is a tree squirrel shootin’, cottontail killin’, meat loving guy like me going to do? I think the answer has been in front of me for a couple of years now, but I failed to see it because I’ve been so hyped up on the .17 rimfire’s speed and destruction (rightly so, btw). Luckily, at the same time this quandary has been lurking in the minds of Mach II shooters, the folks at PMC ammunition have decided to reintroduce the .17 Aguila as the .17 PMC (Varmint & Pest??). Uh oh, I heard the “ugh” that came from many of you. Well, it is probably because the .17 Aguila had a poor showing at the start, or because no gun manufacturers released firearms to shoot it, or that the little bullet goes too darn slow. Before you stop reading and click back over to Fox News or your Google search, hear me out. The folks at Aguila ammunition probably had a bit more forethought than all of us when they released their .17 Aguila back in 2004. After all, they were directing it towards game hunters, who did not want to destroy edible meat when they used their ammo. They also cannot control the firearms manufacturers, but I believe their idea all along was to allow us to re-barrel a current firearm in order to shoot this cartridge. According to the current .17 Aguila/PMC barrel manufacturers, you can re-barrel a Ruger 10/22 with a .17 Aguila/PMC barrel and shoot it with no bolt modifications, but (and here’s the biggie) you can also shoot the .17 Aguila/PMC in your .17 Mach II chambered bolt-action firearm, this time with NO Modifications! So, the answer to the .17 Mach II game friendly bullets seems to be answered, if it’s accurate and performs well. It does, just keep on reading…
Day one testing this round was spent shooting some of the larger ground squirrels we have here in the Southern California Mountains. As everyone should know by now, I have a small game lease with Tejon Ranch, located about 70 miles north of Los Angeles. It is 270,000 acres of ground squirrel heaven, so I knew finding furry targets to shoot with the .17 Aguila/PMC would not be an issue.
The first few shots I took were to sight-in my CZ Model 452 American with the Aguila/PMC rounds. Luckily, I found that I was dead on, but 2” low at 75 yards. That would make it easy when I wanted to switch back to the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) and vice-versa. I shot a final group from my bench, when a fat ground squirrel popped up on a log about 75 yards away. How lucky can I get? Now, we all know that when we are given a shot like this. One we can adjust for and slowly bead down on the target, 9 times out of 10 we over-think it and miss. Well, this was my time to do just that. I missed. Fortunately, the ground squirrel decided to hang around so he could laugh at me a bit. This led to his demise, as the second shot smacked him hard. His entire body stiffened up and he rolled off the log. (You do realize that I could have not even mentioned the first shot and folks everywhere would believe me to be some kind of sniper extraordinaire? But, unlike some of the big name writers who break records with almost every group they shoot, I’m human and sometimes have trigger-farts!!)
Closer inspection of the ground squirrel showed that the bullet hit right where I aimed, high on the shoulder. Unlike the Hornady V-Max bullets, it punched a hole clean through the squirrel and leave a welt-like wound on the exit side (see picture below). It killed the squirrel instantly, but did not leave the body a blown-up, bloody mess. For once, while hunting ground squirrels, this was a positive thing. I knew if I ever turned my sights to game animals, like cottontail rabbit, it would not destroy the edible meat like the V-Max does.
I shot a handful more ground squirrels with the Aguila/PMC round to confirm my findings, and the results were the same, dead squirrels with very little damage to the edible meat portions. Granted, some of my shots were head/neck hits, but most people who consistently shoot the .17HM2, know that even those types of shots will cause great damage, depending on the angle of hit. (click picture for a closer look)
All in all, within the last few months, I spent about 7 full days shooting the .17 Aguila/PMC and burned up 150+ rounds shooting at ground squirrels of various size and weight (and one Starling!!). I truly believe this is a good option for folks who do alot of small game shooting. On the other hand, I found that accuracy and shot placement were more necessary with this round than with the .17HM2. Obviously no one plans on making bad shots, but the poor hits I made resulted in animals that surely died, just not in a place I could retrieve them! I'm positive there were other ground squirrels who were happy about this, as they probably dined heartily on their brethren down in the hole! Most hit by the .17 Aguila/PMC would jump straight up about 6" inches, then walk a foot, fall over and the classic tail wave would signal their demise. I liken the reaction to a heart/lung shot deer, with the results being the same, massive blood loss from a small exit hole, with very little damage to the edible meat. (see picture below):
After spending some quality time with this round I believe it is not for everyone, but most small game shooters should give it a try. I know the feeling of cutting badly damaged meat off an animal hit with a highly explosive bullet. No one wants to waste game meat, but currently, bullets designed for exploding small varmints are the only option right now for the .17HM2. The .17 Aguila/PMC is a viable option when proper bullet placement in the shoulder area are the norm.
Below you will find a brief summary of my findings:
Pros of the .17 Aguila/PMC:
Game bullet = less expansion = less damage to edible meat
Cons of the .17 Aguila/PMC:
Answers to commonly asked questions about the .17 Aguila/PMC:
Can I shoot the .17 Aguila/PMC in my bolt-action rifle that is chambered for the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II)?
--Yes, please re-read my story, it’s obvious you skipped through a bunch of it.--
Can I shoot the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) in a rifle chambered for the .17 Aguila/PMC?
--No, you cannot.--
Where can I purchase .17 Aguila/PMC ammunition and barrels?
Natchez Shooting Supply carries the .17 Aguila version of this ammunition and at press time, it is on sale for $3.92 for a box of 50. I have been told that they carry quite a bit of it, so availability is not an issue at this time. Natchez also offers the Clerke International rifle barrel for the Ruger 10/22 for $89.95. However, from my experience, the description of the round's capabilities (in that ad) is a bit over-stated.
Centurion Arms, which is the United States distributor for Aguila Ammunition, offers direct to consumer purchases of the .17 Aguila version of this ammunition and at press time, it is $64.00 for a brick of 500 rounds.
Midway USA is carrying the .17 PMC version of this ammunition. At press time it was $4.99 for a box of 50, or $90.99 for 1000 rounds.
ER Shaw Custom Gun Barrels offers a .17 Aguila/PMC barrel for the Ruger 10/22 or 77/22 rifle which will allow you to shoot the Aguila/PMC round out of your Ruger with just a barrel swap. At press time the current wait was 12 weeks for one of these barrels. Cost ranges from $109.00 for a standard factory contour barrel up to $205.00 for a fluted, target, bull barrel.- These barrels are no longer available.
Is the .17 Aguila/PMC ammunition going to be available forever?
I don't know the answer to this. While the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) seems to increase in popularity, the .17 Aguila/PMC never really caught on. Therefore, I think a large purchase, in order to save for a "rainy day", is good advice. If Hornady or Fiocchi ever releases the 20 grain game point in the .17HM2 (.17 Mach II) caliber, I believe the Aguila/PMC round will become obsolete.
Did you really kill all those ground squirrels and let that good meat go to waste?
Ground squirrels are vermin. They carry many diseases, including the bubonic plague (aka: black death, black plague, etc). Cannibalistic, they will readily eat the guts of a freshly shot cohort, with complete disregard of the next bullet which probably has their name on it. So, if they are so eager to eat each other, they must taste REALLY GOOD!!
Here is a website with lots of recipes. Just replace the tree squirrel called for in the directions, with ground squirrel! Oh, when you get out of the hospital, let me know how it tasted!
Eric A. Mayer
©1999-2010 Varminter.com Online Magazine